Shingle Roofing Systems Vs Metal Roofing Systems: Missouri Edition

Good morning Missouri! Thomas McCormack here once again from M5 Contracting with another edition of our roofing blog dedicated to helping Missouri homeowners better understand their roofing systems.

Today we’re going to be taking a look at 2 of our most popular roofing systems found in Missouri. Shingle roofing has for a very long time been the most popular choice for Missouri homeowners up until recently when metal roofing started increasing in popularity overall.

Today we’re going to be putting the two in a head to head to find out which is the better option for your Missouri home. Without wasting any further time, let’s dive right in! 

Durability and Weather Resistance

When choosing the right roofing material for your home in Missouri, understanding how each option holds up against the local weather is crucial. Missouri’s climate can be challenging for roofs, with its potential for severe weather, including thunderstorms, tornadoes, high winds, and hail. Here’s a closer look at how shingle and metal roofing systems compare in terms of durability and weather resistance.

Shingle Roofing Systems

Shingle roofs, typically made from asphalt, are the most common roofing material in Missouri due to their cost-effectiveness and straightforward installation. However, their durability can be compromised under severe weather conditions. High winds can lift or even rip off shingles, exposing the underlayment and roof deck to further damage. Similarly, hail can create punctures or strip away the granular surface of the shingles, which is essential for protecting the roof from UV rays and extending its life.

The typical lifespan of asphalt shingles ranges from 15 to 30 years, but this can be significantly reduced if the roof is frequently subjected to harsh weather. Regular maintenance and prompt repairs after weather events are crucial for extending the life of a shingle roof in Missouri.

Metal Roofing Systems

Metal roofs, on the other hand, are gaining popularity among Missouri homeowners for their robust durability and exceptional weather resistance. Made from materials like steel, aluminum, or copper, metal roofs can withstand much harsher conditions. They are highly resistant to wind, with many systems rated to handle wind gusts of up to 140 miles per hour. This feature is particularly important in areas prone to tornadoes and severe storms.

Moreover, metal roofs are virtually impervious to hail damage. While large hailstones may dent some types of metal roofing, this does not compromise the roof’s structural integrity or its ability to protect the home. Another advantage is the longevity of metal roofs; they can last between 40 and 70 years with minimal maintenance, making them a fantastic long-term investment for those looking to stay in their homes for decades.

Conclusion

In summary, while shingle roofs might initially be more affordable, their susceptibility to weather-related damage and shorter lifespan make metal roofing an appealing alternative for Missouri residents looking for durability and peace of mind. Metal roofs offer superior protection against the elements, a longer service life, and could ultimately provide better overall value considering their minimal maintenance needs and exceptional performance in severe weather. For those living in Missouri’s variable climate, the resilience of a metal roof could be the wisest choice for ensuring your home remains safe and secure, year after year.

Energy Efficiency and Insulation

Energy efficiency is a crucial consideration for homeowners in Missouri, where the climate ranges from hot summers to cold winters. The choice of roofing material can significantly impact a home’s internal temperature regulation and, consequently, its energy consumption. Let’s delve into how both metal and shingle roofing systems perform in terms of energy efficiency and insulation.

Metal Roofing Systems

Metal roofs stand out as a premier option for enhancing a home’s energy efficiency. Their inherent ability to reflect solar radiant heat instead of absorbing it is a significant benefit during the hot Missouri summers. This reflective property can help reduce cooling costs by 10-25%, as the metal minimizes the heat transferred into the attic and subsequently into living spaces. This means less reliance on air conditioning, leading to lower energy bills and a cooler home environment.

In winter, though metal roofs are naturally reflective, proper installation with an appropriate insulation layer can help retain heat, reducing the heating costs and keeping the home warm. Furthermore, the smooth, hard surface of metal roofs facilitates the shedding of snow and ice, which helps maintain structural integrity and prevents ice damming—a common winter roofing issue that can lead to leaks.

Shingle Roofing Systems

Traditional asphalt shingle roofs are known for their ability to absorb heat, which can be a disadvantage during the summer months as it potentially increases cooling needs. However, advancements in shingle technology have seen the introduction of specially designed reflective granules that are now integrated into the shingles. These granules help reflect solar energy away from the roof, improving the energy efficiency of shingle roofing systems.

While standard shingles may not naturally offer the same level of insulation as metal roofs, manufacturers have improved the composition of asphalt shingles to better insulate and reflect UV rays. This enhancement helps maintain a more stable temperature inside the home, reducing the burden on heating and cooling systems throughout the year.

Conclusion

In terms of energy efficiency, both metal and shingle roofing systems have their merits and can be suitable for Missouri’s diverse climate. Metal roofs offer superior reflectivity that is beneficial for keeping homes cooler in the summer and can be effective in winter when combined with proper insulation techniques. On the other hand, the newer, more advanced shingle roofs can compete by incorporating reflective technologies that help mitigate the heat absorption drawback, making them a more energy-efficient option than in the past.

Homeowners should consider these factors based on their specific needs, budget, and long-term energy savings goals. For those looking to maximize energy efficiency, metal roofing might be the optimal choice, whereas modern shingle roofs provide a balance of cost-efficiency and improved energy performance.

Cost and Value

When it comes to roofing, the decisions homeowners make are often influenced by both the initial cost and the expected value over time. In Missouri, where the roofing market is diverse, both metal and shingle roofs have their advantages and disadvantages from a financial perspective. Here’s how these two popular roofing options compare in terms of upfront costs, maintenance expenses, and long-term investment.

Initial Cost

Metal roofing systems are typically more expensive upfront than shingle roofing systems. The higher cost is due to the materials used and the specialized labor required for installation. Metal roofs can cost anywhere from 50% to 200% more than asphalt shingle roofs depending on the type of metal used (e.g., aluminum, steel, or copper) and the complexity of the roof design.

In contrast, shingle roofs are generally more affordable and the materials are widely available, which makes them a popular choice among homeowners, especially those facing budget constraints or those not planning to remain in their homes long-term. Shingle roofing materials and installation are less specialized, which keeps costs lower.

Long-Term Investment

Although metal roofs require a higher initial investment, they are often more cost-effective over the long term. Metal roofs can last 40 to 70 years with minimal maintenance, which is significantly longer than the typical 15 to 30 years lifespan of asphalt shingles. The durability of metal roofing means less frequent replacements and potentially lower insurance premiums due to their superior resistance to fire, wind, and hail.

Shingle roofs, while cheaper initially, may require more frequent repairs and sooner replacement. They are more susceptible to damage from Missouri’s severe weather, which can lead to additional costs over time. Frequent replacement and the need for periodic maintenance can diminish the initial savings.

Energy Savings

Another aspect of value comes from energy savings. Metal roofs reflect radiant heat, reducing cooling costs in the summer. These savings accumulate over the lifespan of the roof, potentially offsetting the higher initial cost. Although newer shingle products include energy-efficient options, they typically do not match the energy savings provided by metal roofs.

Resale Value

Metal roofs can also enhance the resale value of a home. Their longevity and durability are attractive features for potential buyers, which can make a home stand out in the market. Shingle roofs, although less costly, might not add as much value to the home, especially if nearing the end of their lifespan at the time of sale.

Conclusion

The choice between metal and shingle roofing systems in Missouri depends heavily on the homeowner’s budget, how long they plan to stay in their home, and their value priorities. Metal roofs offer a better long-term investment due to their durability, low maintenance, energy savings, and potential to boost home value. Shingle roofs, while less expensive initially, may incur higher costs over time due to maintenance and replacement needs. Homeowners must weigh these factors carefully to choose the roofing option that best meets their financial and lifestyle needs.

Aesthetic and Style Variations

When selecting a roofing material, homeowners often consider how it will impact the appearance of their home. Aesthetic appeal is crucial, as the roof can significantly influence the overall look and feel of a property. In Missouri, where architectural styles can vary widely from urban to rural settings, both shingle and metal roofing offer distinct aesthetic and style options that cater to different tastes and home designs.

Shingle Roofing Systems

Shingle roofs are renowned for their traditional appearance, making them a popular choice in residential neighborhoods across Missouri. The classic look of shingles is versatile enough to complement a wide range of architectural styles, from Victorian and Colonial to Craftsman and modern suburban homes. Asphalt shingles come in a variety of colors, textures, and shapes, allowing homeowners to choose a style that enhances their home’s character and curb appeal.

Manufacturers have also developed high-end luxury shingles that mimic the appearance of natural slate or cedar shakes, providing a more sophisticated roofing option without the cost and maintenance associated with natural materials. This variety ensures that regardless of the home’s style or the homeowner’s personal taste, there is likely a shingle option that matches perfectly.

Metal Roofing Systems

Metal roofing, traditionally seen on commercial or agricultural buildings, has evolved significantly and is now a popular choice for residential homes due to its modern, sleek appearance and versatility. Metal roofs offer a clean, contemporary look that can complement both new constructions and renovations. They are available in a variety of finishes, colors, and forms—including panels, shingles, and tiles—that can suit any architectural style.

One of the most appealing aspects of metal roofing is its ability to mimic other roofing materials. Metal can be fabricated to look like traditional shingles, wood shakes, or even tile, offering a durable and long-lasting alternative to those materials with the added benefits of metal’s durability. This versatility makes metal roofs suitable for a broad spectrum of homes, from ultra-modern urban residences to charming country cottages.

Impact on Homeowner Choice

The choice between shingle and metal roofing often comes down to the desired aesthetic and the specific needs of the neighborhood or architectural norms in the area. In urban Missouri settings, homeowners might prefer metal roofing for its modern look and longevity, which complements contemporary home designs. In more rural or traditional neighborhoods, shingles might be favored for their classic, familiar appeal that blends seamlessly with the surroundings.

Furthermore, homeowners must consider the long-term appearance and maintenance of their chosen material. Metal roofs maintain their color and structural integrity longer than most shingles, which can fade and degrade over time. However, the initial higher cost of metal might be a barrier for some, despite its potential to enhance the home’s visual appeal and resale value.

Conclusion

Both shingle and metal roofing systems offer unique aesthetic benefits that can influence a homeowner’s choice based on the architectural style, neighborhood characteristics, and personal preferences. While shingles provide a classic look with vast customization options, metal roofing offers a durable, modern alternative that can adapt to resemble traditional materials. Homeowners in Missouri will find that both options can adequately meet their style and functional needs, making the roof not only a practical shelter but also a statement of personal taste and design savvy.

Maintenance and Repair

The long-term upkeep of a roofing system is a significant consideration for homeowners, impacting not only the longevity of the roof but also the overall maintenance budget. In Missouri, where the weather can be harsh, the choice between metal and shingle roofing systems often comes down to balancing the frequency and ease of maintenance with the availability and cost of repairs.

Shingle Roofing Systems

Shingle roofs, particularly those made of asphalt, are quite common in Missouri due to their affordability and widespread availability. However, they do require more maintenance than metal roofs. Homeowners with shingle roofs should anticipate regular inspections to check for damage such as missing shingles, cracks, or granule loss, which can accelerate the aging of the roof.

After typical Missouri storms, it’s not uncommon for shingle roofs to need repairs due to wind lifting shingles or hail breaking them. These types of damage not only compromise the roof’s ability to protect the home but also can lead to more significant issues like leaks or structural damage if not addressed promptly. Fortunately, repairing a shingle roof is generally straightforward and does not typically require specialized skills. Shingles can be easily replaced by roofing professionals and even by homeowners who are handy and familiar with DIY projects.

Metal Roofing Systems

Metal roofs are prized for their durability and minimal maintenance requirements. They do not suffer from issues like granule loss or cracking. However, they are not completely maintenance-free. In Missouri, where hail and strong winds are common, metal roofs can sustain dents or scratches from hail or flying debris. While these cosmetic damages do not usually affect the roof’s performance, they can detract from the aesthetic appearance and might be bothersome to some homeowners.

When repairs are necessary, they can be more complex and typically require professional service from technicians skilled in metal roofing. This might involve patching holes or replacing entire panels, which can be more expensive and logistically challenging than repairing a few shingles. Additionally, because metal roofing is less common than shingle roofing, finding a qualified contractor available for maintenance or repairs might be more difficult depending on the location.

Considerations for Homeowners

The choice between metal and shingle roofing systems in terms of maintenance and repair involves considering both the frequency of needed repairs and the ease with which they can be conducted. Shingle roofs may require more frequent attention, but repairs are generally easier and less expensive, making this option potentially more appealing for homeowners who anticipate regular maintenance or for those in particularly storm-prone areas of Missouri.

Metal roofs offer the benefit of less frequent maintenance but come with the potential for more challenging repairs if damage occurs. Homeowners must consider the availability of skilled professionals in their area who can perform these repairs, as well as the potential higher cost when these services are needed.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the decision on roofing material should align with the homeowner’s priorities regarding maintenance, repair costs, and the practicality of securing professional service in their area. Both shingle and metal roofs have their merits, but understanding the demands of each in the context of Missouri’s climate and local resources is key to making an informed choice that balances upkeep with durability and cost-effectiveness.

In conclusion, both shingle and metal roofing systems offer unique benefits and challenges for Missouri homeowners. Shingle roofs are cost-effective upfront and offer a traditional aesthetic that suits many architectural styles. However, they may require more frequent maintenance and have a shorter lifespan than metal roofs. On the other hand, metal roofs present a higher initial investment but offer unmatched durability, superior energy efficiency, and minimal maintenance needs. Their modern appearance and adaptability to various styles make them an excellent long-term investment for those planning to stay in their homes for many years. Ultimately, the decision between shingle and metal roofing systems will depend on individual priorities, such as budget, long-term goals, and aesthetic preferences. By carefully considering these factors in light of Missouri’s unique climate, homeowners can select the best roofing option for their specific needs.

If you’re roofing for a roofing contractor you can trust then give us a call today! (573) 415-7221